Monday, September 19, 2011

Best of Week: Three Sisters Dwelling With Us (Heaven be praised!)

The enemies of the Truth, Our Ladies Purity, Chastity, and Modesty, according to the narrator of Orlando, permeate our society.  In a stinging satiric passage we read*,  “For there…dwell…in nest and boudoir, office and lawcourt those who love us [the Sisters]; those who honour us … city men; lawyers and doctors; those who prohibit; those who deny … the still very numerous (Heaven be praised) tribe of the respectable; who prefer to see not; desire to know not; love the darkness; those who still worship us, and with reason; for we have given them Wealth, Prosperity, Comfort, Ease.” 

And oh, how true this has been since Virginia Woolf died!  One can only guess what Virginia Woolf would have written about 21st-century society if she, like her characters, had been able to live in several centuries.  I found this satirical view of the world to be the best idea we tossed around in English class this week.  Our society rewards deception in many arenas: climate change; running shoes; and even as Woolf pointed out, specifically mentioning doctors, our health care industry to name a few.

When Virginia Woolf committed suicide, she knew nothing of the mess that is now known as the “health” care industry in America, yet she still accused doctors of being Truth-hiders.  Perhaps she was just using doctors as an example of an occupation, accusing the common member of society of being a Truth-hider with no specific grievance germane to doctors.  Nonetheless, I feel particularly compelled to single out this aspect of society today, seeing as we have just read The Healing of America.

The myth that our Western system of medicine perpetuates, that we can solve illness simply by running tests and prescribing medication without addressing any underlying emotional or mental causes, was addressed by my mom when she spoke to our class about wellness.  For those who have the audacity to think that the Western system cannot be the full solution, all too often our health care industry will descend with its veil in the form of a notice that says coverage of holistic or mental health practice has been denied.  (Surely if we don’t pay for mental health, we will return more wealth to our shareholders!) They deny the truth, blind like Our Lady Modesty, covering us like Our Lady Purity.  If anyone thinks that the health care industry has not enjoyed Wealth, Prosperity, Comfort, and Ease from this lie, please share your belief in comment form.

Freezing us, like Our Lady Chastity, is another nasty habit of the health care industry—that is, with fear —running oodles of tests on us, and pushing vaccination after vaccination to shield us from random exotic diseases.  On occasion, it comes out that these vaccines have harmful side effects.   

An incident of this nature happened not so long ago to my grandmother who received an alarming phone call from her doctor at a later-than-usual hour for a phone call from the doctor.  “The result of your test indicates that you might have bone marrow cancer.”  Having high blood pressure, this alarming news sent her into quite a state.  She promptly called another of her doctors immediately to proscribe her a pill to calm her.  

As she talked to yet another doctor, the next day, she was told that a more accurate phone call might have been at a more reasonable hour and in a gentler tone saying, “The result of your test indicates that you may potentially have a slightly heightened risk of developing an extremely rare form of bone marrow cancer sometime from now, but please have no reason to be alarmed.”  But of course this crazy system of tests is easier and cheaper for the doctors since these excessive tests protect them from malpractice lawsuits!

Being raised in the household that I have, I have been blessed to be aware of many Truths about wellness.  When I am older, I will have to choose the Truth over the Ease of our grossly oversimplified proscribe-and-rid-the-illness system.

But wait, more examples!

Attention all runners: you have been told the lie by the running shoe industry for several decades now, that well-padded shoes are good for your feet.  As more evidence comes out, it seems that to the contrary, excessive shoe padding creates multiple health risks in the long-term.  It appears that our footwear friends have deceived us!  What incentive would they have to change, when they can enjoy Wealth, Prosperity, Comfort, and Ease?

Upton Sinclair once said, “It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.”  When we have wealth, what incentive do we have to change our ways?  Both Sinclair and Woolf arrive at the same notion—that there is a fundamental flaw in society that prioritizes wealth over truth.  Al Gore used this Sinclair quote in An Inconvenient Truth in reference to the big oil companies’ not changing their ways to deal with the reality of climate change as well as in reference to the tobacco industry post-Surgeon-General's report. The very title—An Inconvenient Truth—seems to suggest that while it is inconvenient to change our ways, even lose money, to do the right thing, we must allow the trumpets of Truth to blare forth.  We must regard the Three Sisters, and indeed our society, with a watchful eye.  What this satirical view of society has caused me to realize is that we are faced with these obstacles of ignorance every day--because they pay well.  To me, the Truth is more important, a judgement call each individual must make for his/herself.


*pages 101-02 of our edition

Monday, September 12, 2011

Carry It Forward: Orlando

Knowing that death is inevitability, how should we live our lives in the short time that we are here?  This is a question that virtually every civilization and person has sought an answer to.  We have so many possible paths to take; choices are overwhelming! 

One such path is obscurity—an idea that Virginia Woolf wrestles with in Orlando.  Whereas in the first chapter, Orlando writes to liberate himself from obscurity, he comes to somewhat of an epiphany under the oak tree upon looking at his house in the second chapter; he comes to think that obscurity is, indeed, one of the desirable paths which one can follow in life.

I never thought I would find myself compared to a time-travelling, androgynous Elizabethan, but here it goes: I, like Orlando once did, thought obscurity was for losers.  Look at the good things that have happened in history.  It is written by well-known names.  But in a deeper sense, history surely is composed also by each and every obscure person.  What Woolf seems to be getting at is that there is a distinction between the impact one can have on society if attention and prestige are not on the individual priority list.  Let us examine a benefit of obscurity which Woolf does not:

Woolf justifies obscurity by saying it allows for consciousness—by living in the moment.  The text reads*, “It [obscurity] … allows giving and taking without thanks offered or praise given…Shakespeare must have written like that, and the church builders built like that, anonymously… ‘What an admirable life this is,’ he thought…. ‘And why not enjoy it in this very moment?’”  Woolf leaves the reader to wonder why giving and taking without thanks offered or praise given is superior to any other form of giving.

The subject of giving and taking without thanks offered or praise given is reminiscent of a teaching of Maimonides, a great thinker of the eleventh and twelfth centuries, who more elaborately explored this.  One of his teachings was an eight-level ladder of charity, in which each rung was more desirable than the one below. 

The fourth best level is when a person gives without knowing to whom he or she gives, but the recipient knows the identity of the donor; the third best is when a person gives without making his or her identity known; and the second most desirable level of giving is when neither the donor nor the recipient know the identity of each other.  (It seems a bit discourteous of me to list numbers two, three, and four, and leave you wondering what is highest level of generosity—it’s when someone enables others to help themselves, but that’s another discussion.)

It is clear that the motive behind generosity is a major factor in determining its goodness according to Maimonides.  Absent the “thank yous” of society it seems consequent that the true nature of human generosity would be more prevalent, a world where the foundation of people’s generosity is the sole purpose of giving.  As a duty.

Although Maimonides was talking more in a context of charity, it seems plausible to me that the way one gives, in a broader sense, to society, works in much the same way.  In the tradition of the vast majority of the thousands of generations before us, whose names we know not. Obscurity allows one to go about improving society with less ego and selfishness intervening.  These contributions to the world we make continue to exist, just as Orlando says his ancestors, in their obscurity, changed the house and left it to him.  In addition to the advantages Woolf mentions, all of the stupid and artificial components that come with generosity can be overcome by ceding our problematic identities to noble obscurity.


*page 77 our our edition.