Monday, May 14, 2012

Blogging Around


 
1. Jack discussed how the acting and director’s decisions in A Midsummer Night’s Dream at Chicago Shakespeare Theater made his experience so enjoyable.

Jack, I also found myself looking through the playbill when writing the Midsummer blog entry because I wrote about the choice the director made to set the play in the 1920s.  I noticed that the director had chosen to switch the first two scenes of the play, too, but I didn’t write about it, and I really didn’t know what to think of it until I read your blog.

First, I agree with you that this is clear evidence of the director’s comfort with Shakespeare and that he was making conscious decisions.  This means that the enjoyment of the production doesn’t solely rest on the shoulders of Shakespeare and the actors. 

So in terms of altering Shakespeare’s plays, how far is too far?  How much can a director push the conventional interpretation of Shakespeare to the forefront of his or her imagination and creative interpretation?  What you picked up on is that as long as the director is knowledgeable and making a conscious decision, chances are the production is going to be set for success. 

By changing those first two scenes, the director really improved the play for modern times.  I think a 21st century audience would have had a bad first impression of the play if it had opened with Act I, scene I.  It simply would have been too boring.  I don’t think Shakespeare would roll over in his grave for this choice.

 
2. Katy, my Jane Eyre mashup partner, discussed the course of her thinking during the project and how she was able to analyze and accept the relationship between reason and love.

Katy, I think we both went into this project with at least one concern in common: that there would not be enough textual evidence in the book to back up our claim, which you seemed more skeptical about than I did from a gut-feeling standpoint.  With that being said, I was surprised to see that you were so shocked and yet so willing to pursue the thesis that we did, considering that you characterized yourself as stubborn.  (Which, by the way, I think you really exaggerate.)

I think I also had a hard time accepting that there was a rational side of love that “works” because I didn’t really pick up on the fact that it is a part of Jane Eyre until the later chapters with St. John.  I didn’t like what I saw.  In fact, I kind of hated St. John.

Eleven pieces of evidence from the beginning, middle, and end of Jane Eyre seemed daunting, and for a day or so I was truly convinced that working in a duo would be a bad idea because it required that we gather extra evidence.  At first I also thought we’d have to take passages out of context.   (Not to be confused with the “decontextualizing” and “recontextualizing” that was called for... I mean straight-up twist sections of Jane Eyre into the mashup.)

Given that we were both so skeptical I was wondering why in the world we ended up pursuing the complicated mashup we did from the start.  Part of my reasoning was simply that if you thought it was crazy, you probably would have either decided to work with someone else or convinced me that we needed to change our direction entirely. 

In other words, since you didn’t think it was insane, that lead me to believe the same thing.  I suspect that if we had been working alone, neither of us would have had the courage to pursue the thesis that we did. 



Monday, May 7, 2012

Dialectics: Freedom and Responsibility


Conventional wisdom would state that knowledge is a source of freedom.  From a macro-perspective this seems to make sense.  The earliest of mankind’s discoveries freed up enough time for specialization of labor to develop.  The development of new ideas are liberating.  Plato’s Allegory of the Cave seems to define freedom in terms of what we do or do not know.

This seems to hold true at the level of the individual in The Matrix.  Knowledge and the pursuit of the truth are desirable, because that is the only way to escape the matrix—the “system.”  This is probably the interpretation which the authors wished the viewers to arrive at.  Otherwise, the criticism that Postmodernists are nihilists would be apply to this movie as well.

But this knowledge and this responsibility of fighting the matrix doesn’t feel like freedom to some of the characters in the movie.  When Neo got to choose which pill to take, he took on the incredible responsibility of “saving the world.”  Did he take a step in the direction of freedom?  Or, rather, did he actually sacrifice freedom?

The relationship between freedom and responsibility isn’t a new one.  Even Shakespeare explored the idea in Henry VII, Part II, when Henry VII says, “Uneasy lies the head that wears a crown.”  It seems to make logical sense that freedom and responsibility trade off with each other.

The Matrix seems to suggest something entirely different: that in a Postmodern world where there is a “matrix”, we have the responsibility as individuals to create our own freedom.  We can use the power of our minds and our knowledge to battle our way to freedom.

At the same time it calls into question to what extent freedom is good.  When the agents are eating their steak and one of them says, “I know it’s not real.  But you know what?  Ignorance is bliss,” it articulates the antithesis of the responsibility to find freedom: the ignorant and illusory “free” existence which Neo had before he chose to fight the Matrix. 

Relating back to the Allegory of the Cave, if you only know one reality and it seems free to you are you free?  So we are then left with an epistemological question.  Is freedom just a big illusion?

Friday, April 27, 2012

Metacognition: Jane Eyre Mashup


I was expecting to come to some sort of epiphany halfway through the mashup and change directions.  But Katy and I had a very specific and solid idea from the beginning which we stuck to throughout the project, tweaking our thesis only slightly.  We knew from the beginning that we wanted to explore the relationship between rationalism and emotion in terms of love. 

It seemed daunting at first, because the only obvious evidence seemed to be at the end of the novel.  But as we explored earlier chapters, we found a lot of good evidence did exist and it was clear to us that we had struck a less pronounced but still powerful and relevant them in entire novel. 

A lot of times, I think in very specific ways about projects, or literature in general.  Too specific sometimes, at first, but I am capable of taking these specific ideas and then changing them completely if necessary, as I did with the early stages of my short story.  This just wasn’t one of those times where radical change was necessary.  I’m still trying to figure out if this is a good strategy or if it is too bold.

Here’s another explanation of that point: if Katy and I had been having a conversation with our peers about what we wanted to do for our mashups, say, three minutes after class, people would have looked at me funny if I proclaimed in a collected tone, “the dialectics between rational thought and human emotions and how they relate to the love that Saint John experiences and the love that Jane experiences throughout the novel.”  But I think the joke’s on them, and I hope you’ll agree.

This was just one of those cases where it was possible to take a precise thought and run with it.  If I were to do a mashup again, I think it would be worthwhile to let the specific ideas go if only to have the experience of starting in a broad way and then narrowing in on something cool.

As we moved further into the project we discussed how we wanted to sequence things.  Ultimately, we realized that there was no “rational” section and there was no “emotional” section of the mashup.  We allowed the mashup to freely weave back and forth because we discovered that there were simply better transitions to be made than piling our evidence in two stacks and going from there.  After all, was Jane not conflicted about what love is?  This is when we saw that both parts of love are inevitably part of the human mind and that the mashup should reflect that.

We found that many of our elements explained or explored the relationship between the two “sides” of love and therefore lay in between.  This was what sequencing needed to be centered around.  A lot of our elements either fit naturally together because they were saying the same thing just in totally different contexts (which I think are the coolest transitions) or we were able to make things connect better using analysis, which also turned out well.  Less frequently, we researched something very specific for the purpose of connecting two ideas.

Every step of the way, I think Katy and I surprised ourselves.  Our concerns that our theme was hyper-specific and that we should have started more broadly were erased as we starting cranking out analysis and outside connections.  Perhaps it was a stroke of luck, perhaps we just happened to pick up on an idea that lent itself well to a mashup format. 

I found that the act of working with a partner also lent itself well to the mashup format.  At first I didn’t think I would want to work with a partner because it seemed like it would just be way too much work during a relatively busy week, but when Katy suggested to me that having two minds on this could be particularly good for this project, I saw her logic.  This was definitely the right choice. 

Those moments where we would say, “OH! I know what’s perfect.  Remember that chemistry commercial?” or "Hey, check out these song lyrics," or the moments when we had a bunch of elements printed and cut out on a kitchen counter and we were momentarily stumped trying to arrange them and then one of us saw a brilliant idea that the other wouldn’t have seen allowed us to better accomplish the task at hand. 

The moments where we called each other out on poorly planned connections or bad textual evidence also should not be understated.  As we have learned throughout the year, there are times where you just need to let ideas go as part of the creative process.  Some of these ideas might have been usable in a world where we had infinite time to work on the Jane Eyre mashup, but presenting the most compelling evidence took precedence.

I don’t know if a trio would have been overwhelming, but landing up in duo-land from the reading quizzes was a good place to be after all.  I would find it hard to believe that those who worked alone and those who worked in groups of three did not have vastly different experiences than I did.

While I can’t say that the mashup saw me to see a new theme in Jane Eyre, I can say that it will help me to analyze love in literature in a more sophisticated way.  I can also say that I got me thinking about the way society views love, and more generally, how the mind works--and how the relationship between rational thought and our emotions constantly determine the way we make decisions. 

Friday, April 6, 2012

Change of Mind: Setting Shakespeare's Plays


Before I saw Chicago Shakespeare Theater’s rendition of A Midsummer Night’s Dream, set in the year 1920, I really didn’t like the idea of Shakespeare’s plays being set in non-traditional times.  I just didn’t buy MacBeth with leather jackets and lots of strange scaffolding, or as my mom has told me she once saw performed, motorcycle gang Romeo and Juliet.  

Perhaps this is because I was in a production of Romeo and Juliet set in the “normal” way, and I just couldn’t conceive of doing Shakespeare any other way because I’d never seen it done successfully.  I’d like not to think it’s because I’m an uncreative, boring person who’d rather just see everything done the plain way.

But A Midsummer Night’s Dream was absolutely incredible.  With Shakespeare, the writing is a given—so what I would imagine separates the good shows apart from the bad ones are the acting and the way the play is edited and set by the directors.  The acting was great in this show, but I’m still not entirely sure why they decided to set the play in the 1920s.  I found it just appealing enough to catch my interest but not strange enough to be distracting.

Mr. Gary Griffin, the Associate Artistic Director of Chicago Shakespeare Theater and director of this particular show wrote in the program, “We located the year as 1920—soon after World War I ended.  Here in America, there was a renewed vision of hope.  It was a time when a lot of groups of people were starting to encounter each other for the first time, and there was a new progressive view of the world.”

I read this over a few times and still didn’t quite understand.  Obviously the director saw some connection between hope and A Midsummer Night’s Dream.  The way he made this connection in the play seemed to be the idea that Puck, the overseer of the play, was Sigmund Freud, who believed that dreams are depictions of our self-desires. 

So when my parents asked me how the play was, the first thing I told them was that it was great, and naturally the second thing I told them was that it was set in 1920—and they gave me a strange look.  I simply tried to explain to them that it worked!  It really did.  I couldn’t tell you with absolute certainty why that is, but then again, that’s why I’m not the artistic director of Chicago Shakespeare Theater.

Fundamentally, the director is making an interpretation of what Shakespeare thinks about dreams.  It’s a deep and powerful statement, and one that I don’t think I could have derived were it not for the blurb in the program.  But it’s clear to me now that a lot of thought goes into these decisions, and the setting is clearly meant not to save money or to merely make things more appealing to a 21st century audience, but rather to support the emotional narrative of the writing itself. 

The more I think about it, I really do think that 1920 might have actually been an incredible choice to set this play in.  The imagery of the 1920s in the costumes, in the props, et cetera, really do seem to conjure up the whimsical and funny spirit which plays well off of the preternatural fairy world.  

So is it okay in my opinion (to all you imaginary artistic theatre directors out there who take heed to my 10th-grade English blog posts) to creatively take a Shakespeare play and put in in a different time period? As long as it isn’t wild enough to distract me the acting... go for it.

Thursday, March 22, 2012

Metacognition: Short Story


Archery was a short story about a boy who leaves his house (where his abusive father lives) to go play with his archery set.  He accidentally injures a dog and tries to doctor it up, but only succeeds in injuring it further.  The father hears the noises of the dog’s pain and in a surprising moment comes to see what is the matter.  The boy and his father share a difficult but meaningful moment together at the end of the story: they shoot the dog and the father proclaims, “That ought to put an end to its misery.” This is a far cry from the story’s inception.

The first draft of my short story was about as close to crap as possible.  I had no clue where it was going, a silly plot line, complicated yet bland characters, and an overly-complex and very hypothetical “message” I was trying to communicate about forgiveness and the way people treat each other.  Two men were having a conversation in a ski lift.  When I turned it in, I immediately knew that I was going to need to start over.

I threw it out.  But despite how bad it was, I do honestly believe it got me to a better place.  I decided to retain two ideas in my next draft: the snowy, white (clean, fresh start) landscape and the idea of a boy watching his father kill his dog which was mentioned by one of the men on the ski lift.  In the next draft, I thought the middle of the story would be the father killing the dog cruelly and the boy would pull the dead dog on a sled through the storm to the dog’s master’s house in an act of apology.  There were a couple of fatal flaws with this though.  First, it was utterly unrealistic for the father to be such a heartless character.  And secondly, I didn’t know deep down what the dog’s master could possibly say that would make an effective ending.

And thus I faced three questions while writing my final draft.  Who should my main character be—the father or Daniel (previously named David)?  How can I put more pressure on my main character?  How can I make a more powerful and believable father character and ending?  I also deleted some of the back-story and the characters which seemed to detract from the real story: the relationship between the father and the boy.

I decided that the main character should definitely be Daniel.  I felt like if I made the father the main character, the ending would inevitably lead to the same exact message as Stone Boy, which wasn’t precisely the direction I wanted to head… While the story is indeed about the relationship between the father and the boy, I could see why someone might say that the father has more at stake, more to learn, etc.  It was a tough call, because I even went as far as to try to draw a parallel between the dog and Daniel when I referred to the “master” bedroom of Daniel’s father and the dog’s “master”.   

But I felt that it would be more effective to show Daniel’s pain because he is the one who has made the mistake of shooting the dog, and he could do more in the story that would actually demonstrate the father’s character.  (But has his father not made mistakes, too, in terms of Daniel?  I know, I know…)  What really forced me into this decision was the logistics of the story in terms of setting and plot—how to tell a story about something going on outside if the main character is inside did not seem feasible—and I thought it would just be more interesting.  I believe either could have worked, they just would have felt totally different.  More thought went into this than I feel I should post on this blog.

To put more pressure on Daniel and to show the father character more, I decided I could kill two birds with one stone.  I made Daniel sneak into the house and go into his father’s bedroom to look for something to cure the dog and then lie to his father.  Using details rather than explaining a backstory, I was able to understand a lot about the father.  Daniel rooted around in his father’s medicine cabinet, which contained a huge collection of “God-knows-what” pills.  This invaded the privacy of the father. 

I “stole” this idea of privacy invasion from our short story unit.  Just so name a couple of other “stolen” ideas, I used the storm as a means of pressure from King Lear, the rhythm and pace from the ending of Cathedral during the ending of my story. 

The ending of the story was probably the most painful to write, but also, in my opinion, the most emotionally powerful part.  I kind of surprised myself that I came up with such a sick, twisted story in the first place when I wrote this.  It seemed clear from the details in the story that the father and Daniel didn’t really do a whole lot together.  So what if, I thought, to change their emotional states, they share a painful moment together that also provides some closure for the story? 

Just hearing the gunshot alone would be an abrupt and clichéd ending, and it wouldn’t really present any sort of interesting question.  I played around with having Daniel and his father talk about the situation or Daniel thinking something the way Arnold did in Stone Boy, but to me, it killed the pace and it wasn’t nearly as effective as what I came up with.  Instead, I had Daniel fall back into his father’s arms and have the father say, “That ought to put an end to its misery.”  It presents an interesting question: while the misery of the dog is finished off at the end, is the misery of Daniel beginning to finish off, too, in terms of his relationship with his father because they have finally shared something and he has seen his father do something that he called “humanitarian”? 

The story seems to suggest that this was a good moment for them to endure, but it is up to the reader to wonder about what the future of their relationship will look like.  Maybe there is a little nuance that even I'm not seeing yet, and I can communicate even better with my next draft of the story.  And yet, as jam-packed as any short story is, you can only show one moment and its implications--not tell the story of an entire lifetime.  It's all about picking and choosing the most important details.

Monday, March 12, 2012

An Inconvenient Truth: "The White Man's Burden" and Kony 2012 ... iew


There is no doubt in the minds of most people that the West’s imperialism of Africa left the continent in shambles – economically, politically, et cetera.  What was called “The White Man’s Burden” seemed like justification to many Europeans at the time for the “protection” of the world’s “uncivilized” people.  Through our multi-perspective examination of this time period in class, reading works by Joseph Conrad, George Orwell, and Chinua Achebe, we took a deeper look at what this burden really meant.

To the 21st century academic, “The White Man’s Burden” was wholly unjustified.  The notion that one culture has the obligation to do what it believes is right for another culture in this instance was wrong.  But the line begins to break down at some point.  When people of a nation insist on denying what is perceived as “basic human rights” to its own citizens, is it okay to interpose?  Even when some people object?

By now you’ve probably heard of Invisible Children’s effort, Kony 2012*, – to spread awareness about the current nightmare in Central Africa created by Joseph Kony’s LRA.  In a sentence, the LRA abducts children into their rebel army and forces them to kill or be killed.  Invisible Children is an organization based in the United States and it is using social media and inspiring young people in an effort to improve the lives of thousands of negatively affected Africans through a multitude of programs.  And yet some choose to brand this as imperialism.    

Dayo Olopade wrote on a New York Times blog, “And when, as in this case, success is determined by action from outside the region, cries of a new imperialism should be taken seriously . . . .  Let’s not amplify and reproduce another narrative of Africa in crisis when Ugandans themselves are moving on.”**

I genuinely believe that what Invisible Children is doing is right because... well I believe it, many of the people around me agree with it, and yes most Ugandans would probably not object to Invisible Children’s so-called imperialism.  (It pains me to hear people call it imperialism.)  But I recognize that I have no more right to say that these people’s perspectives are wrong than would some European missionary 130 years ago. 

I wish that at least I could understand them better!  To me, it is an amazing cause using new social media to inspire millions and change the world.  To others, it is simply another arm of the Western imperial monster.  This is the inconvenient truth of what some call modern imperialism and others call protecting human rights.


*To watch the half-hour video “Kony 2012” visit: http://vimeo.com/invisible/kony2012

Friday, February 10, 2012

Carry It Forward: Heart of Darkness


One of the more memorable images in Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness is a map of Africa which Marlow sees in the city that reminds him of a “whited sepulchre.”  The map is literally colorful, but it has a much darker emotion.  It is divided up in ways that don’t make sense to the people living there, and Marlow describes where he is going as “dead in the centre.”  (Dead has more than one meaning here.)  The map is only the tip of the iceberg for him.
                                                                                                                                      
We talked in Social Studies about how when the Europeans rapaciously divided Africa, no attention was paid to tribal boundaries.  We looked at a map of tribal regions which bore no resemblance whatsoever to the borders of imperial or modern Africa.  I can’t help but think what Joseph Conrad would say if he could see a map of Africa today—and see how the very borders that he witnessed the carving of are playing out.
                                  
This got me thinking more generally about what maps can really convey and why they were so interesting during the time period that Heart of Darkness was written.  We know that the first extensive maps of Africa were originally created by Europeans.  Once they had done this, they had the power of new knowledge, and this allowed them to systematically and brutally divide up the continent.  What if there hadn’t been good maps of Africa by the year 1880?  Why did Conrad go into so much depth about this one in particular?                  
                                                                                                                                                                                          
What Conrad truly did was a remarkable job of putting the entire emotion of this time period on a map in a novel.  I had never really thought about how different someone 113 years ago and I might look at the very same map in two completely different ways.  Marlow comments on the red, marking the British Empire, “good to see…because one knows that some real work is being done in there…” (10). 

To the modern-day reader, this map is odious—to helplessly watch these tragedies unfold in the name of some greater “work.”  And we can only guess how Conrad might have viewed it!  It’s so easy to think, “Come on, all this ‘White Man’s Burden’ and racist stuff Marlow seems to think have to be Conrad’s ironic way of speaking to us—he must have been against imperialism as a whole, right?  Or else, surely he wouldn’t have described Africa as such a dark place!  (Or the human mind for that matter.)  He wouldn’t have made this map the way he did.”  But given some of the more racist things said by Marlow in Heart of Darkness which don’t seem the same way like the “dog in a parody of breeches”, many readers agree it is more likely that Conrad just had an objection to this specific instance of imperialism. 

What intrigues me so much about this map is that a European reader of Heart of Darkness in 1899 would interpret the very same map in a totally different way.  Maps are a powerful symbol for us because they are the mechanism by which we visualize the world.  Through maps, we understand who controls what.  But do we really?  I think sometimes we need to challenge the way we look at maps, and where they came from, especially when it comes to Africa, because they do not tell the entire story!  Marlow had to go into this map to discover what was really “dead in the centre.” If we have never been somewhere, then a map is usually the means by which we come to understand the perceived boundaries of something.  It is easy to be deceived by the simplicity of a map’s lines.  In the case of Africa, a muli-perspective, historical understanding of imperialism is needed.
                                                                                                                                                                                          
After all, the map in Heart of Darkness is this very same map that British children would have looked at just a century ago instantaneously understood that the neat, red shapes belonged to their empire.  Who’s to say that we understand every “line” on the globe today the way we ought to?  I look forward to continuing to learn this year in school about why borders are the way they are today, because if every region of the world even half as complex as Africa is, I will look at maps in a different light (or lack thereof).