Knowing that death is inevitability, how should we live our lives in the short time that we are here? This is a question that virtually every civilization and person has sought an answer to. We have so many possible paths to take; choices are overwhelming!
One such path is obscurity—an idea that Virginia Woolf wrestles with in Orlando. Whereas in the first chapter, Orlando writes to liberate himself from obscurity, he comes to somewhat of an epiphany under the oak tree upon looking at his house in the second chapter; he comes to think that obscurity is, indeed, one of the desirable paths which one can follow in life.
I never thought I would find myself compared to a time-travelling, androgynous Elizabethan, but here it goes: I, like Orlando once did, thought obscurity was for losers. Look at the good things that have happened in history. It is written by well-known names. But in a deeper sense, history surely is composed also by each and every obscure person. What Woolf seems to be getting at is that there is a distinction between the impact one can have on society if attention and prestige are not on the individual priority list. Let us examine a benefit of obscurity which Woolf does not:
Woolf justifies obscurity by saying it allows for consciousness—by living in the moment. The text reads*, “It [obscurity] … allows giving and taking without thanks offered or praise given…Shakespeare must have written like that, and the church builders built like that, anonymously… ‘What an admirable life this is,’ he thought…. ‘And why not enjoy it in this very moment?’” Woolf leaves the reader to wonder why giving and taking without thanks offered or praise given is superior to any other form of giving.
The subject of giving and taking without thanks offered or praise given is reminiscent of a teaching of Maimonides, a great thinker of the eleventh and twelfth centuries, who more elaborately explored this. One of his teachings was an eight-level ladder of charity, in which each rung was more desirable than the one below.
The fourth best level is when a person gives without knowing to whom he or she gives, but the recipient knows the identity of the donor; the third best is when a person gives without making his or her identity known; and the second most desirable level of giving is when neither the donor nor the recipient know the identity of each other. (It seems a bit discourteous of me to list numbers two, three, and four, and leave you wondering what is highest level of generosity—it’s when someone enables others to help themselves, but that’s another discussion.)
It is clear that the motive behind generosity is a major factor in determining its goodness according to Maimonides. Absent the “thank yous” of society it seems consequent that the true nature of human generosity would be more prevalent, a world where the foundation of people’s generosity is the sole purpose of giving. As a duty.
Although Maimonides was talking more in a context of charity, it seems plausible to me that the way one gives, in a broader sense, to society, works in much the same way. In the tradition of the vast majority of the thousands of generations before us, whose names we know not. Obscurity allows one to go about improving society with less ego and selfishness intervening. These contributions to the world we make continue to exist, just as Orlando says his ancestors, in their obscurity, changed the house and left it to him. In addition to the advantages Woolf mentions, all of the stupid and artificial components that come with generosity can be overcome by ceding our problematic identities to noble obscurity.
*page 77 our our edition.
No comments:
Post a Comment