Monday, May 14, 2012

Blogging Around


 
1. Jack discussed how the acting and director’s decisions in A Midsummer Night’s Dream at Chicago Shakespeare Theater made his experience so enjoyable.

Jack, I also found myself looking through the playbill when writing the Midsummer blog entry because I wrote about the choice the director made to set the play in the 1920s.  I noticed that the director had chosen to switch the first two scenes of the play, too, but I didn’t write about it, and I really didn’t know what to think of it until I read your blog.

First, I agree with you that this is clear evidence of the director’s comfort with Shakespeare and that he was making conscious decisions.  This means that the enjoyment of the production doesn’t solely rest on the shoulders of Shakespeare and the actors. 

So in terms of altering Shakespeare’s plays, how far is too far?  How much can a director push the conventional interpretation of Shakespeare to the forefront of his or her imagination and creative interpretation?  What you picked up on is that as long as the director is knowledgeable and making a conscious decision, chances are the production is going to be set for success. 

By changing those first two scenes, the director really improved the play for modern times.  I think a 21st century audience would have had a bad first impression of the play if it had opened with Act I, scene I.  It simply would have been too boring.  I don’t think Shakespeare would roll over in his grave for this choice.

 
2. Katy, my Jane Eyre mashup partner, discussed the course of her thinking during the project and how she was able to analyze and accept the relationship between reason and love.

Katy, I think we both went into this project with at least one concern in common: that there would not be enough textual evidence in the book to back up our claim, which you seemed more skeptical about than I did from a gut-feeling standpoint.  With that being said, I was surprised to see that you were so shocked and yet so willing to pursue the thesis that we did, considering that you characterized yourself as stubborn.  (Which, by the way, I think you really exaggerate.)

I think I also had a hard time accepting that there was a rational side of love that “works” because I didn’t really pick up on the fact that it is a part of Jane Eyre until the later chapters with St. John.  I didn’t like what I saw.  In fact, I kind of hated St. John.

Eleven pieces of evidence from the beginning, middle, and end of Jane Eyre seemed daunting, and for a day or so I was truly convinced that working in a duo would be a bad idea because it required that we gather extra evidence.  At first I also thought we’d have to take passages out of context.   (Not to be confused with the “decontextualizing” and “recontextualizing” that was called for... I mean straight-up twist sections of Jane Eyre into the mashup.)

Given that we were both so skeptical I was wondering why in the world we ended up pursuing the complicated mashup we did from the start.  Part of my reasoning was simply that if you thought it was crazy, you probably would have either decided to work with someone else or convinced me that we needed to change our direction entirely. 

In other words, since you didn’t think it was insane, that lead me to believe the same thing.  I suspect that if we had been working alone, neither of us would have had the courage to pursue the thesis that we did. 



Monday, May 7, 2012

Dialectics: Freedom and Responsibility


Conventional wisdom would state that knowledge is a source of freedom.  From a macro-perspective this seems to make sense.  The earliest of mankind’s discoveries freed up enough time for specialization of labor to develop.  The development of new ideas are liberating.  Plato’s Allegory of the Cave seems to define freedom in terms of what we do or do not know.

This seems to hold true at the level of the individual in The Matrix.  Knowledge and the pursuit of the truth are desirable, because that is the only way to escape the matrix—the “system.”  This is probably the interpretation which the authors wished the viewers to arrive at.  Otherwise, the criticism that Postmodernists are nihilists would be apply to this movie as well.

But this knowledge and this responsibility of fighting the matrix doesn’t feel like freedom to some of the characters in the movie.  When Neo got to choose which pill to take, he took on the incredible responsibility of “saving the world.”  Did he take a step in the direction of freedom?  Or, rather, did he actually sacrifice freedom?

The relationship between freedom and responsibility isn’t a new one.  Even Shakespeare explored the idea in Henry VII, Part II, when Henry VII says, “Uneasy lies the head that wears a crown.”  It seems to make logical sense that freedom and responsibility trade off with each other.

The Matrix seems to suggest something entirely different: that in a Postmodern world where there is a “matrix”, we have the responsibility as individuals to create our own freedom.  We can use the power of our minds and our knowledge to battle our way to freedom.

At the same time it calls into question to what extent freedom is good.  When the agents are eating their steak and one of them says, “I know it’s not real.  But you know what?  Ignorance is bliss,” it articulates the antithesis of the responsibility to find freedom: the ignorant and illusory “free” existence which Neo had before he chose to fight the Matrix. 

Relating back to the Allegory of the Cave, if you only know one reality and it seems free to you are you free?  So we are then left with an epistemological question.  Is freedom just a big illusion?