Image above captioned: “Children of Israeli setllers play in a bouncy castle next to the ruins of the illegal outpost of Maoz Ester, near Kokhav Ha Shahar settlement, east of Ramallah on June 4, 2009. The wildcat outpost has been dismantled by Israeli authorities several times over the past few months, only to be re-erected within hours by zealous settlers. (YEHUDA RAIZNER/AFP/Getty Images)”
Israel is no doubt condemned on the world stage quite frequently, and validity to these condemnations often varies.
Israel is no doubt condemned on the world stage quite frequently, and validity to these condemnations often varies.
Israel set up the Gaza strip reasonably well-equipped for success, but we all know what happened there. Hamas was elected and investments made not in schools or infrastructure, but in rockets. A six-month ceasefire was signed, during which time thousands of rockets were launched at Israel, while Israel waited, and waited, and waited for the ceasefire to expire before invading. Israel went out of its way to avoid innocent civilian casualties in various ways, and perhaps for what cannot be explained, more detailed analysis aside, we give them the benefit of the doubt. This is not the sort of instance (in my mind) in which Israel ought to be scrutinized.
But what is this West Bank settlement nonsense?! Given the opportunity to answer such a question, a more eastward-looking Israeli might rattle off a couple asinine remarks:
- It’s our land, it says so in our religion, ‘nuff said. It’s what I believe. You can’t touch that.
- We can use this as bargaining leverage to get the Palestinians to stop doing unwanted things.
- It’s vital to the security of the State of Israel.
What I find appalling is that the majority of Israelis don’t even support these settlements! I’d like to believe that the Israelis truly desire peace, and I think they do. But how can Benjamin Netanyahu maintain that he wants a two-state solution while the Israeli population is burgeoning throughout the West Bank? And even if there are so-called “approved settlements” I had no clue until seeing the pictures on this website that these “unsanctioned” settlements were such a problem that the Israeli government was actually tearing them down!
This being said, I know a lot of stuff circulates on the internet and the media, especially on Israel, and even more specifically in wrongly captioned photos. I’m obviously working under the assumption that the image I found is credible, and it seems relatively plausible, consistent with things I’ve read, but one can never be too sure. For more on this visit http://honestreporting.com/.
My first reaction to this image was that it sickens me. The Israeli government, what little credit I give it on the issue of settlements in the West Bank, has perhaps attempted to control the situation, evident by the fact that the settlement depicted above has been torn down. (I use the word control loosely, like a toddler using the handbrake on his bike as he zooms down the slope of Mount Everest attempts to control his speed.) The bouncy castle seems wildly inappropriate and eerily juxtaposed.
And as relatively “pro-Israel” American Jew, a secondary emotion is embarrassment. I believe Israel has the right to exist. I’m not interesting in taking this post in the direction of why I might be said to support Israel, but I’m well aware upon seeing instances like these that support cannot be blind.
Part of the reason this photo is shocking is because the age of the children in the picture. Most of them look pretty young. It’s always difficult to watch young children be brought up with negative feelings which we would not want for ourselves. It takes no wild logic to infer that these children are being brought up by radical, land-hungry Israeli parents. After all, they are repeatedly defying their own government in a bid to put up this settlement. The extent to which the settlers are going to put up these settlements are always frightening and intriguing to me.
Perhaps a lesson here for all of us is that we need to raise children to the best of our ability, with tolerance, and without ultra-radical ideals. What kind of world are we creating? And what are we going to do about the situation in the West Bank?
The photo posted here, among other interesting photos on this issue can be found at http://www.boston.com/bigpicture/2009/06/israeli_settlements_in_the_wes.html. As always, feel free to comment on my beliefs or my sources.
No comments:
Post a Comment