1. Jack P., "An Inconvenient Truth: Success"
Jack, I think in high school a lot of us are contemplating success. You’ve articulated the inconvenient truth that “success” as we know it is not guaranteed. You’ve also articulated your own vision of success: that one who is successful enjoys life deals and well with other people.
Jack, I think in high school a lot of us are contemplating success. You’ve articulated the inconvenient truth that “success” as we know it is not guaranteed. You’ve also articulated your own vision of success: that one who is successful enjoys life deals and well with other people.
This, to me, was a clear and concise way of addressing what I have also been thinking about for a while – I couldn’t agree more! However there’s a couple other aspects that I sometimes think about: darker, more selfish things that sometimes people have a tendency to over-focus on. Power, wealth, fame. These things, you and I would agree, are not a measure of success.
You do however touch on an idea of “changing the world” or “benefiting society” on a grandiose scale which you brand as cliché. While I agree with you that this is not the most important thing—that the way one deals with people on a more micro-level is a must—is there room in your interpretation of success for this? I’ve thought about it like this:
I think that this idea of benefiting society is very much a part of the aspect of success that deals with relationships with other people. It doesn’t have to be some enormous thing, but it certainly can. To some, religion tells them how to interact with other people. To others, it is a more unique and personal set of values. Your notion of success is somewhat subjective, but that’s the beauty of it—we each must find our own success. Whatever the mechanism is for each individual to determine what constitutes a “good” way to deal with others and to be happy every day, I find the idea that success is simple to be a pleasant one. We can leave a mark on other people based on our behavior which does have a ripple effect. The way we treat people every day is of paramount importance because our moods, actions, and words often affect those of others.
Dealing honestly and favorably with our fellow human beings doesn’t preclude any sort of financial success, high status, etc. The question becomes then whether these things come by coincidence, as a byproduct of seeking true success, or whether it is possible to pursue both simultaneously. Seeking out true success certainly isn’t mutually exclusive with the possibility of fame—take Gandhi for example.
So I was wondering if your idea of success has room for this idea of “benefiting society”, and secondly, if that is what you are aiming for. Or are you are resigned strictly to a simpler notion of success in the hope that your personal peace and kindness will improve the lives of others?
2. Julia J., Research: Shakespeare
Julia researched a couple of Shakespearian Experts: Simon Callow, an English actor and director, and Patsy Rodenburg, voice coach and theatre director. She posted a link to a video in which Callow attempted to get his class to connect with Shakespeare’s characters and promised to find a speech for each student to match what he or she aspired to be. Rodenburg had an experience in which an audience member approached him saying that he didn’t like theater—an actor in a play had hauntingly made a disturbing noise not to different from that made by a police officer while informing this audience member that his daughter had been raped and murdered.
Julia researched a couple of Shakespearian Experts: Simon Callow, an English actor and director, and Patsy Rodenburg, voice coach and theatre director. She posted a link to a video in which Callow attempted to get his class to connect with Shakespeare’s characters and promised to find a speech for each student to match what he or she aspired to be. Rodenburg had an experience in which an audience member approached him saying that he didn’t like theater—an actor in a play had hauntingly made a disturbing noise not to different from that made by a police officer while informing this audience member that his daughter had been raped and murdered.
Julia, I’d like to thank you for posting the link to the video of Simon Callow. I watched it and found him to be a really interesting teacher. I love the idea of asking students to find a Shakespearian character to associate themselves with and having them perform a Shakespearian monologue. #misterallen
One thing he mentioned in the video is that students should memorize their monologues because it means more than reading it off of a paper. I mentioned in one of my blog posts how valuable my participation in Romeo and Juliet has been to my understanding of the play, and, more generally, Shakespeare. Although I don’t feel like the Prince is a character I relate much to, acting that part allowed me to crawl around inside those lines, and now, if I look at any given line of his in R&J, I feel a stronger connection to it.
I agree with you that the thing that makes Shakespeare so great is the characters. Have people really changed that much? Characters still have recognizable flaws. We can sit in the audience and have knots in our stomach as we see what Lear cannot the same way the audience four hundred years ago would have. We can feel the same emotions; we can cry as Juliet speaks to the “happy dagger.” Lewd wisecracks are still funny.
But then again his writing is a testament to how little as well as how different times were back then. We laugh at Shakespeare when Kent insults someone with the line, “whoreson, cullionly barbermonger!” We might cringe at the anti-Semitism in Shakespeare’s words while Shylock demands a pound of human flesh or the Witches in Macbeth throwing into their cauldron some “liver of blaspheming Jew.”
What’s remarkable is that despite these pronounced differences between our society today and Shakespeare’s, the writing endures as clever, heart-wrenching, and humorous. I think what Callow did with his students is a great exercise. Hopefully someday I’ll come across a Shakespearian character that I have a very strong connection with.
(And I recommend all readers pay a visit to the Random Shakespearian Insult Generator: http://www.pangloss.com/seidel/Shaker/)
No comments:
Post a Comment