Thursday, March 22, 2012

Metacognition: Short Story


Archery was a short story about a boy who leaves his house (where his abusive father lives) to go play with his archery set.  He accidentally injures a dog and tries to doctor it up, but only succeeds in injuring it further.  The father hears the noises of the dog’s pain and in a surprising moment comes to see what is the matter.  The boy and his father share a difficult but meaningful moment together at the end of the story: they shoot the dog and the father proclaims, “That ought to put an end to its misery.” This is a far cry from the story’s inception.

The first draft of my short story was about as close to crap as possible.  I had no clue where it was going, a silly plot line, complicated yet bland characters, and an overly-complex and very hypothetical “message” I was trying to communicate about forgiveness and the way people treat each other.  Two men were having a conversation in a ski lift.  When I turned it in, I immediately knew that I was going to need to start over.

I threw it out.  But despite how bad it was, I do honestly believe it got me to a better place.  I decided to retain two ideas in my next draft: the snowy, white (clean, fresh start) landscape and the idea of a boy watching his father kill his dog which was mentioned by one of the men on the ski lift.  In the next draft, I thought the middle of the story would be the father killing the dog cruelly and the boy would pull the dead dog on a sled through the storm to the dog’s master’s house in an act of apology.  There were a couple of fatal flaws with this though.  First, it was utterly unrealistic for the father to be such a heartless character.  And secondly, I didn’t know deep down what the dog’s master could possibly say that would make an effective ending.

And thus I faced three questions while writing my final draft.  Who should my main character be—the father or Daniel (previously named David)?  How can I put more pressure on my main character?  How can I make a more powerful and believable father character and ending?  I also deleted some of the back-story and the characters which seemed to detract from the real story: the relationship between the father and the boy.

I decided that the main character should definitely be Daniel.  I felt like if I made the father the main character, the ending would inevitably lead to the same exact message as Stone Boy, which wasn’t precisely the direction I wanted to head… While the story is indeed about the relationship between the father and the boy, I could see why someone might say that the father has more at stake, more to learn, etc.  It was a tough call, because I even went as far as to try to draw a parallel between the dog and Daniel when I referred to the “master” bedroom of Daniel’s father and the dog’s “master”.   

But I felt that it would be more effective to show Daniel’s pain because he is the one who has made the mistake of shooting the dog, and he could do more in the story that would actually demonstrate the father’s character.  (But has his father not made mistakes, too, in terms of Daniel?  I know, I know…)  What really forced me into this decision was the logistics of the story in terms of setting and plot—how to tell a story about something going on outside if the main character is inside did not seem feasible—and I thought it would just be more interesting.  I believe either could have worked, they just would have felt totally different.  More thought went into this than I feel I should post on this blog.

To put more pressure on Daniel and to show the father character more, I decided I could kill two birds with one stone.  I made Daniel sneak into the house and go into his father’s bedroom to look for something to cure the dog and then lie to his father.  Using details rather than explaining a backstory, I was able to understand a lot about the father.  Daniel rooted around in his father’s medicine cabinet, which contained a huge collection of “God-knows-what” pills.  This invaded the privacy of the father. 

I “stole” this idea of privacy invasion from our short story unit.  Just so name a couple of other “stolen” ideas, I used the storm as a means of pressure from King Lear, the rhythm and pace from the ending of Cathedral during the ending of my story. 

The ending of the story was probably the most painful to write, but also, in my opinion, the most emotionally powerful part.  I kind of surprised myself that I came up with such a sick, twisted story in the first place when I wrote this.  It seemed clear from the details in the story that the father and Daniel didn’t really do a whole lot together.  So what if, I thought, to change their emotional states, they share a painful moment together that also provides some closure for the story? 

Just hearing the gunshot alone would be an abrupt and clichéd ending, and it wouldn’t really present any sort of interesting question.  I played around with having Daniel and his father talk about the situation or Daniel thinking something the way Arnold did in Stone Boy, but to me, it killed the pace and it wasn’t nearly as effective as what I came up with.  Instead, I had Daniel fall back into his father’s arms and have the father say, “That ought to put an end to its misery.”  It presents an interesting question: while the misery of the dog is finished off at the end, is the misery of Daniel beginning to finish off, too, in terms of his relationship with his father because they have finally shared something and he has seen his father do something that he called “humanitarian”? 

The story seems to suggest that this was a good moment for them to endure, but it is up to the reader to wonder about what the future of their relationship will look like.  Maybe there is a little nuance that even I'm not seeing yet, and I can communicate even better with my next draft of the story.  And yet, as jam-packed as any short story is, you can only show one moment and its implications--not tell the story of an entire lifetime.  It's all about picking and choosing the most important details.

No comments:

Post a Comment