Conventional wisdom would state that
knowledge is a source of freedom. From a
macro-perspective this seems to make sense.
The earliest of mankind’s discoveries freed up enough time for
specialization of labor to develop. The
development of new ideas are liberating.
Plato’s Allegory of the Cave seems
to define freedom in terms of what we do or do not know.
This seems to hold true at the level
of the individual in The Matrix.
Knowledge and the pursuit of the truth are desirable, because that is
the only way to escape the matrix—the “system.”
This is probably the interpretation which the authors wished the viewers
to arrive at. Otherwise, the criticism
that Postmodernists are nihilists would be apply to this movie as well.
But this knowledge and this
responsibility of fighting the matrix doesn’t feel like freedom to some of the
characters in the movie. When Neo got to
choose which pill to take, he took on the incredible responsibility of “saving
the world.” Did he take a step in the
direction of freedom? Or, rather, did he
actually sacrifice freedom?
The relationship between freedom and
responsibility isn’t a new one. Even
Shakespeare explored the idea in Henry
VII, Part II, when Henry VII says, “Uneasy lies the head that wears a
crown.” It seems to make logical sense
that freedom and responsibility trade off with each other.
The
Matrix seems to suggest something entirely different: that in a Postmodern
world where there is a “matrix”, we have the responsibility as individuals to
create our own freedom. We can use the
power of our minds and our knowledge to battle our way to freedom.
At the same time it calls into
question to what extent freedom is good.
When the agents are eating their steak and one of them says, “I know
it’s not real. But you know what? Ignorance is bliss,” it articulates the
antithesis of the responsibility to find freedom: the ignorant and illusory
“free” existence which Neo had before he chose to fight the Matrix.
Relating back to the Allegory of the Cave, if you only know
one reality and it seems free to you are you free? So we are then left with an epistemological
question. Is freedom just a big illusion?
*correction: Henry IV
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteYour perception, Matthew, of the dialectic between freedom and responsibility forced me to question my definition of those terms as a continuation of our complex discussions about The Matrix in English. I always regarded and bondage between freedom and responsibility commonly attributed to both national security and how I lead my life at school and the outside world. I never thought that the concept of freedom could be paradoxical when applied to The Matrix.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, you identify that in the Matrix, inhabitants have intellectual, social, and physical freedom; they can involve in any activities, as long as it does not disrupt the solidarity of the cyberspace complex. Usually, many people would state that the “enlightened ones,” which include Morpheus, Neo, and Trinity have more freedom than those in the Matrix. However, you state that, in actuality, Neo and his companions are sacrificing their freedom and placing on themselves the responsibility and burden of “saving the world.”
Even though it may seem that the Matrix is better as it allows for more “freedom,” the cyber-complex instigates a lot more selfishness due to the “individual” nature. Inhabitants are inclined to find freedom for only themselves. However, in the real world, Neo, Morpheus, Trinity, and others aboard the Nebuchadnezzar are placing the fate of humanity on their own hands. Can this be a representation of the individuality of our society today? Are we all selfish, ignorant of the “frame narratives” that every different person possesses?
So, is freedom clearly defined in any of the elements of the dialectic that you articulated? Is the chance that Morpheus gave to Neo to choose between two pills the most pure example of freedom in this film? Your blog entry introduced, overall, a new concept onto the scene of comparing and contrasting the real world and the Matrix. Nice!