Monday, March 12, 2012

An Inconvenient Truth: "The White Man's Burden" and Kony 2012 ... iew


There is no doubt in the minds of most people that the West’s imperialism of Africa left the continent in shambles – economically, politically, et cetera.  What was called “The White Man’s Burden” seemed like justification to many Europeans at the time for the “protection” of the world’s “uncivilized” people.  Through our multi-perspective examination of this time period in class, reading works by Joseph Conrad, George Orwell, and Chinua Achebe, we took a deeper look at what this burden really meant.

To the 21st century academic, “The White Man’s Burden” was wholly unjustified.  The notion that one culture has the obligation to do what it believes is right for another culture in this instance was wrong.  But the line begins to break down at some point.  When people of a nation insist on denying what is perceived as “basic human rights” to its own citizens, is it okay to interpose?  Even when some people object?

By now you’ve probably heard of Invisible Children’s effort, Kony 2012*, – to spread awareness about the current nightmare in Central Africa created by Joseph Kony’s LRA.  In a sentence, the LRA abducts children into their rebel army and forces them to kill or be killed.  Invisible Children is an organization based in the United States and it is using social media and inspiring young people in an effort to improve the lives of thousands of negatively affected Africans through a multitude of programs.  And yet some choose to brand this as imperialism.    

Dayo Olopade wrote on a New York Times blog, “And when, as in this case, success is determined by action from outside the region, cries of a new imperialism should be taken seriously . . . .  Let’s not amplify and reproduce another narrative of Africa in crisis when Ugandans themselves are moving on.”**

I genuinely believe that what Invisible Children is doing is right because... well I believe it, many of the people around me agree with it, and yes most Ugandans would probably not object to Invisible Children’s so-called imperialism.  (It pains me to hear people call it imperialism.)  But I recognize that I have no more right to say that these people’s perspectives are wrong than would some European missionary 130 years ago. 

I wish that at least I could understand them better!  To me, it is an amazing cause using new social media to inspire millions and change the world.  To others, it is simply another arm of the Western imperial monster.  This is the inconvenient truth of what some call modern imperialism and others call protecting human rights.


*To watch the half-hour video “Kony 2012” visit: http://vimeo.com/invisible/kony2012

2 comments:

  1. Matt,
    I have to say you raise a curious thought. I had never imagined the invisible children organization as the current way of imperialism. I always looked at the organization as a charitable act of kindness and respect for human rights. Never once did it cross my mind that it could possibly be the total opposite. What we believe to be honestly helping from the bottom of our hearts, could actually turn out to the most current form of chaos-causing imperialism. The comparison between this organization and "The White Man's Burden" is almost impeccable. Although I don't like to think about it because it would turn something that I believe positive into something cruel, the fit is perfect. It is our way of justifying our not-so-nice actions by saying that we need to help the less fortunate, exactly like the European missionaries 130 years ago.

    ReplyDelete
  2. For starters, it's always interesting to see the many shades and lenses different people have for viewing the world and global affairs; what's charity for some is just short of aggression to others. That being said, when there are such opposing view like those brought up on polarized sides of the world, I usually find that the real story, or the most accurate way to perceive a situation is to find the shade of grey. In this case, we'd have be able to see that the actions taken by Invisible Children may seem a little intrusive to proud Central Africans who know the West's history of trying to control their affairs. While our motives have drastically shifted, from the land-grabbing brutes from 150 years ago, to upstanders for human rights, the fact is we are deliberately engaging in foreign matter that doesn't directly concern us as a country. That being said, the Africans should realize our shift and discern a helping (or maybe just concerned) hand from imperialism. Is it our duty to introduce our American muscles into an African conflict? Absolutely not. It would seem far worse, however, if we recognized a problem and stood idly by when we knew we could at least attempt to help stop it. Of course, I have a sort of skewed perspective myself, it would seem rude and un-called-for if the French all of a sudden decided to give every homeless person in America $100. So is it better to respect their nationalistic beliefs, or protect what we view as international human rights? The fact that the two are even confused sure is inconvenient, but from the outsider's point of view (seeing as I myself am in no position to make any executive decisions on the matter) I guess I can appreciate the fact that to make an informed and considerate decision, we have to be able to acknowledge the other sides point of view, and respect it to the extent that it needs to be respected. So maybe a few less 30 minute short films would help our cause, but with or without them, I suppose our first priority is always to do what's right. So long as it is right...

    ReplyDelete