Friday, April 27, 2012

Metacognition: Jane Eyre Mashup


I was expecting to come to some sort of epiphany halfway through the mashup and change directions.  But Katy and I had a very specific and solid idea from the beginning which we stuck to throughout the project, tweaking our thesis only slightly.  We knew from the beginning that we wanted to explore the relationship between rationalism and emotion in terms of love. 

It seemed daunting at first, because the only obvious evidence seemed to be at the end of the novel.  But as we explored earlier chapters, we found a lot of good evidence did exist and it was clear to us that we had struck a less pronounced but still powerful and relevant them in entire novel. 

A lot of times, I think in very specific ways about projects, or literature in general.  Too specific sometimes, at first, but I am capable of taking these specific ideas and then changing them completely if necessary, as I did with the early stages of my short story.  This just wasn’t one of those times where radical change was necessary.  I’m still trying to figure out if this is a good strategy or if it is too bold.

Here’s another explanation of that point: if Katy and I had been having a conversation with our peers about what we wanted to do for our mashups, say, three minutes after class, people would have looked at me funny if I proclaimed in a collected tone, “the dialectics between rational thought and human emotions and how they relate to the love that Saint John experiences and the love that Jane experiences throughout the novel.”  But I think the joke’s on them, and I hope you’ll agree.

This was just one of those cases where it was possible to take a precise thought and run with it.  If I were to do a mashup again, I think it would be worthwhile to let the specific ideas go if only to have the experience of starting in a broad way and then narrowing in on something cool.

As we moved further into the project we discussed how we wanted to sequence things.  Ultimately, we realized that there was no “rational” section and there was no “emotional” section of the mashup.  We allowed the mashup to freely weave back and forth because we discovered that there were simply better transitions to be made than piling our evidence in two stacks and going from there.  After all, was Jane not conflicted about what love is?  This is when we saw that both parts of love are inevitably part of the human mind and that the mashup should reflect that.

We found that many of our elements explained or explored the relationship between the two “sides” of love and therefore lay in between.  This was what sequencing needed to be centered around.  A lot of our elements either fit naturally together because they were saying the same thing just in totally different contexts (which I think are the coolest transitions) or we were able to make things connect better using analysis, which also turned out well.  Less frequently, we researched something very specific for the purpose of connecting two ideas.

Every step of the way, I think Katy and I surprised ourselves.  Our concerns that our theme was hyper-specific and that we should have started more broadly were erased as we starting cranking out analysis and outside connections.  Perhaps it was a stroke of luck, perhaps we just happened to pick up on an idea that lent itself well to a mashup format. 

I found that the act of working with a partner also lent itself well to the mashup format.  At first I didn’t think I would want to work with a partner because it seemed like it would just be way too much work during a relatively busy week, but when Katy suggested to me that having two minds on this could be particularly good for this project, I saw her logic.  This was definitely the right choice. 

Those moments where we would say, “OH! I know what’s perfect.  Remember that chemistry commercial?” or "Hey, check out these song lyrics," or the moments when we had a bunch of elements printed and cut out on a kitchen counter and we were momentarily stumped trying to arrange them and then one of us saw a brilliant idea that the other wouldn’t have seen allowed us to better accomplish the task at hand. 

The moments where we called each other out on poorly planned connections or bad textual evidence also should not be understated.  As we have learned throughout the year, there are times where you just need to let ideas go as part of the creative process.  Some of these ideas might have been usable in a world where we had infinite time to work on the Jane Eyre mashup, but presenting the most compelling evidence took precedence.

I don’t know if a trio would have been overwhelming, but landing up in duo-land from the reading quizzes was a good place to be after all.  I would find it hard to believe that those who worked alone and those who worked in groups of three did not have vastly different experiences than I did.

While I can’t say that the mashup saw me to see a new theme in Jane Eyre, I can say that it will help me to analyze love in literature in a more sophisticated way.  I can also say that I got me thinking about the way society views love, and more generally, how the mind works--and how the relationship between rational thought and our emotions constantly determine the way we make decisions. 

No comments:

Post a Comment